Islamorada Fish Company Reviews
Reviews
We're all about trust. Our community relies on honest reviews to help you make those big decisions with ease.
4.9 out of 5 rating
![WeddingWire Couples' Choice Awards 2024 Winner]()
4.9 out of 5 rating
106 reviews
97% recommend it
Awards
-
Featured
![Bailey]()
Bailey S. Sent on 06/05/2023Most Amazing Venue 🤩🌴
First off, all the props need to go to Jill and her staff. These people are remarkable. From communication to decorating, bartending, serving delicious food..this venue has it all. The sunset that we got was amazing!! You can’t beat the views of the ocean and palm trees. Jill put out all my decor and decorated my cake with what I had brought and what she had on hand. I truly didn’t lift a finger that day. You can tell everyone there loves what they do. Jill is so good at her job and I am so thankful for her and all she did to make our day so special. Also a major plus is the bridal suite. It’s stunning. You can eat lunch up there and have drinks. It’s an awesome set up. All these other venues want an arm and a leg and it was so hard finding something within budget but this place fell right into my lap. It’s affordable and the most perfect place for a destination wedding. Look no further because the Islamorada Fish Company is the place. ❤️ -
-
![Aliese]()
Aliese H. Sent on 04/05/2024Best day ever!
We got married on March 23, 2024 at Islamorada Fish Company and it was magical. There are no words to describe how amazing Jill Stewart is. She listened to all my wants, visions and dreams and was very helpful and patient during the whole planning process. I did not know until later on that I accidentally ordered my wedding cake for pick up instead of delivery and Jill without saying anything to me left, picked up my cake and had it back at the reception in perfect time. Everything was perfect. Transitions from ceremony to cocktail to reception went flawlessly. I also recommend using their day of coordinator if you book (which you should) she is so sweet, helpful and has a great eye for detail and a very fun yet calming demeanor. The food was outstanding, all the staff was so kind and the venue is breathtaking. There are truly no words to describe how amazing March 23, 2024 was. Thanks to Jill and the staff of IFC it was truly the best day ever!
-
Beatriz C. Sent on 04/05/2024
Phenomenal night
First of all... I want to say thank you to Jill and her team for making my wedding such a phenomenal night. All the details that I wanted, they made it come true! The day coordinator was worth every dollar! She helped me with the table settings and everything else that was needed. I would recommend this venue to anyone who is looking to get married in paradise, while not breaking your wallet! -
-
![Krissy]()
Krissy G. Sent on 03/09/2024Absolutely get married at IFC!
My husband and I got married at IFC on March 1st and are absolutely in awe of the team, especially Jill Stewart and our day-of coordinator, Marissa. They kept me updated throughout the day as the team set up the decor and truly went above and beyond to make our day absolutely perfect.
As an event planner myself, I knew we were in good hands the minute I met Jill. Throughout the planning process, she was attentive, helpful, and so respectful of our budget.
When childcare for one our attendants' fell through at the last minute, her lovely daughter Lexie stepped in as their babysitter.
Not all heroes wear capes, but Jill, Marissa, and the IFC staff were the absolute heroes of our special day. If you are considering IFC for your wedding location, you should absolutely book with them today! -
-
![Guillermo]()
Guillermo G. Sent on 01/19/2024Worth Looking into it
Amazing venue, amazing staff. Granted we had a small wedding but nevertheless everything went very smoothly. From the bridal suite to the ceremony to the dinner to the after party.
I would highly recommend. -
Barbara V. Sent on 01/04/2024
Awesome venue and location!!
Where do I start? From the first phone call with Jill, EVERYTHING went sooooo smoothly!!!! Location, location, location- can’t beat it, especially with the beautiful sunset we had!!!! Food was AMAZING and Marissa (Coordinator) was FANTASTIC!! IT WAS AN AWESOME WEDDING for my daughter!!! -
-
![Tracey]()
Tracey G. Sent on 01/02/2024Jill Stewart and her Fabulous Team went Above and Beyond to make our Wedding Day perfect!
I have to say, I don't think I could've planned a wedding from our home town in Colorado to the Florida Keys without the extraordinary help from Jill Stewart and her wonderful team from the Islamorada Fish Company! Jill was extremely supportive, patient, kind, fun and just a "gem" to work with! She made it seamless for us right from the start and kept in touch with me so I didn't have to worry about anything. Our reception was amazing!! The hors d'oeuvres, the salads, dinners and the unbelievable cake from Maggie's Bakery, Key Largo, was by far the best food I've ever had! Her team was so great and they were all so HAPPY to be there! If you are looking for a Top Notch team, who will go above and beyond to make your wedding/reception the best ever, the Islamorada Fish Company is the place to choose! Thank you Jill and your WONDERFUL staff for all you did to make our night so special! ~ Tracey and Roland -
Ashley V. Sent on 01/13/2024
Breathtaking wedding
What an amazing wedding day! I got married at the Islamorada Fish Company on Dec 2 2023 from beginning to the very end Jill and her staff were absolutely amazing. Every detail to every aspect of our wedding was covered and didn’t have to worry about anything. Let me tell you about the food, so delicious and yummy. Every guest enjoyed their meal and mentioned how it was the best wedding food they had. My husband and I are very happy with our event and memories we made. Thank you Jill and her team to our wonderful day! -
-
![Sarah]()
Sarah Sent on 12/29/2023The most amazing wedding!
We got married on October 28th 2023 and it could not have been more incredible! The venue was able to make accommodations for us to make the day more than perfect! -
-
![Katy]()
Katy H. Sent on 10/13/2023The most special place :)
Islamorada Fish Company will forever hold the most special place in our hearts. The venue is absolutely stunning, the bridal suite is perfect, but most of all, Jill and the rest of the IFC team are incredible to work with. Fantastic communication and organization, budget friendly, GREAT food and drinks, but above all, the staff really cares about making your day the best it can be... and ours was! They went to SO many extra lengths to make us feel special and loved, and we will never forget it. BOOK THIS VENUE! You will not regret it. -
-
![Paul]()
Paul A. Sent on 05/03/2023Best Day or our LIVES!!!
I would like to just say first and foremost how thankful my wife and I are for the amazing staff that worked so hard to make our day perfect. Islamorada Fish Company was the perfect venue for our wedding with around 70-75 guests. Jill, the wedding planner is easy to get ahold of and always quick with a solution when problems arise. My family was lucky enough to have both our rehearsal dinner as well as our wedding there and it was superb. First off, the staff is incredible. It is nice to surround yourself with hard working people that also seem genuinely happy for you. Special thanks to Jamie the bartender, she was amazing and always charming and made amazing drinks. The day of coordinator is a must! There was no stress on the wedding day. Jill was quick to answer any questions as well as offer advice for decorations, vendors, food choices etc. It has been 2 weeks since our wedding and looking at just normal pictures taken the venue is beautiful, and it blows everyone away that I show here in Ohio. We did some light planning and knew a couple specific things that we wanted and the day of the wedding was seamless, non stressful and amazing. When you are there all you have to do is follow the lead of Jill and her staff, they do something like 100 weddings a year at that venue so trust me, they know 100% what they are doing. While we were taking pictures somewhere else on the property they have a young lady watching us to ensure we didn’t forget anything such as phones, jackets, glasses etc. which we did and thank goodness for her. The Fish Company has every angle covered. To summarize, we could not be more happy with this venue. All the food was hot, tasty and fresh, the price was reasonable and the staff truly makes it a wonderful experience. Oh, also the natural beauty of the water, trees, sand and amazing sunset. To the entire staff at the Islamorada Fish Company, we thank you so much for your hard work, professionalism and amazing service that gave us the wedding of our dreams! -
![Ariel]()
Ariel Sent on 05/03/2023The absolute best day ever!!!!
My husband and I just got married at the Islamorada fish company April 21, 2023 and they surpassed all of our expectations with flying colors. We are from Ohio, so having a destination wedding I was extremely nervous. From wanting to have certain decorations brought in and certain accommodations made, I felt this would be impossible. Jill made each and every want possible. Her attention to detail and more importantly the love for her job made everything so effortlessly incredible. The day of the wedding was breath taking and an absolute dream. The entire staff made my husband and I feel like we didn't even have to lift a finger. There was no stress about anything because they handled everything so flawlessly. We also hired the day of coordinator and her assistant, and I highly recommend as they added so much ease to the entire process. From setting up decorations, ensuring all of our needs were met, to even following us around during our pictures to ensure everyone's belongings were safe! They literally thought of every single detail and everything was perfect. My husband and I could not thank them enough. Each and every single one of their staff members were so pleasant and enjoyed what they did so much, it honestly felt like a big family coming together to throw an amazing party. So if you are thinking about having your wedding at this venue.. DO IT!!!!!!!!! because they strive for perfection and they will not disappoint you. -
![Sam]()
Sam E. Sent on 04/25/2023The best venue ever!
The most incredible venue we could've asked for! We planned a destination wedding here for March 2023. Jill (and Brad) were so helpful the whole time and made destination planning so easy. When we got to town, everyone on the venue property was so helpful and kind. The day of the wedding was just perfect! The bridal suite was wonderful. Drinks, food, and decorations were amazing. Also the views here are just beautiful! Cannot recommend this venue enough! -
-
![Emma]()
Emma V. Sent on 04/23/2023Best Day Ever!
We already knew Islamorada Fish Company for their restaurant; One of our favorite spots when we are in the Keys. When we discovered they offered a wedding venue we were afraid it was too good to be true. It was every bit as amazing as we thought it would be! Jill Stewart, the coordinator at IFC, was so knowledgable and so supportive from the start. She walked us through the whole process from our first call to our last. She made planning a wedding long distance as painless as anyone could ever hope for. IFC offered many options when it came to the decor, colors, layout, seating...every aspect. Jill never made us feel like what we wanted on our day was too much or not attainable. All of that was before the wedding day. We were so sure that we would need to be there for set up and coordination. No. Jill and her crew were ABOVE AND BEYOND!! They were all attentive and professional. The ceremony and reception spaces looked gorgeous, they ensured we were settled and comfortable, all set up was completed well before the necessary time and all of our guests were taken care of from the moment they arrived.
There are so many moving parts that go in to a wedding, and the staff at IFC manages them without batting an eye; from the largest to the smallest. My wife and I were talking, recapping our separate experiences the day of the wedding, and realized the person that did the most to calm us before the ceremony, was one of our assigned IFC staff members. Leslie was the last person I talked to before I walked down the aisle and she honestly, gave me peace and perspective. Throughout getting ready, walking down the aisle, more pictures than I care to recount, Jill was there all along with a reassuring smile and a cool drink. That experience and patience is worth every penny a person could spend and IFC was still so affordable; the most affordable of the places that we looked throughout the Keys. Looking back, even for more money, I would not have picked another venue. When I see pictures of our sunset ceremony and our families dancing under the stars...Would. Not. Trade. It!! Thank you, Islamorada Fish Company for the truly unforgettable day!! All our IFC staff were VIPs, special shoutouts to Leslie, Jamie, and Jill..saved the day. -
![Courtney]()
Courtney P. Sent on 04/09/2023Best Wedding Venue Ever
I'm so glad I picked Islamorada Fish Company as the venue for our destination wedding on April 3rd 2023 in Islamorada, FL. It was so beautiful there and Jill was amazing to work with. She made sure everything was perfect for that day and any questions I had over the course of planning, she would answer right away, or schedule calls if she was busy, and helped to make the entire process as stress free as possible.
The staff went above and beyond for our wedding day by always checking to see that we were taken care of and making sure the decorations looked beautiful. Even after four events they had over that weekend, they were still friendly, energetic and ready to help with anything. The bridal suite was amazing to get ready in and I was able to watch everything being set up from the balcony.
Islamorada Fish Company made sure that my wedding was as stress free as possible and all I can remember was how perfect that day was. The location was gorgeous, the food was absolutely delicious, everyone was helpful and you could tell that they knew what they were doing, and the atmosphere had the Keys vibe of taking your worries away.
I would highly recommend this venue to anyone wanting an amazing, stress-free destination wedding down in the Florida Keys. It was worth every penny and I wouldn't change a thing about my wedding there. -
-
![Jocelyn]()
Jocelyn D. Sent on 03/14/2023Amazing!
JILL STEWART!!!! Wow.wow.wow. My dream was to get married in Islamorada!!! I found this venue by chance through another brides post on Facebook…. And WOW am I so glad I took her advice! This venue is unbelievable!!! The first time I met Jill (the wedding coordinator) she makes you feel SO at ease with all the wedding details and planning! Literally I only had to tell her my ideas on how I wanted things to go and look on our day and she literally did even BETTER!!! She literally took my ideas and went above and BEYOND! When I saw everything decorated for the first time I lost it! She is so amazing I can not say enough on how outstanding her and her staff are!!! The organization was absolutely incredible!! I got to enjoy every single moment and not have to worry about a SINGLE thing!!!! Because I knew Jill had it all taken care of!!!! It’s truly a breath of fresh air! Not only is she literally the sweetest person and so so easy to talk and coordinate with she’s literally the best in this business hands down. Our entire wedding party said they’ve been to SOO many weddings and our wedding was literally the BEST wedding they’ve ever attended!! We can’t recommend this venue ENOUGH!!!! If your dream is to get married in the keys like mine was…. Stop looking anywhere else. THIS IS THE VENUE!!! You will thank me later!!! Thank you Jill & Marissa, and all your top notch staff. You guys are absolutely amazing and we can’t thank you all enough!!! 10000000 stars!!!! -
-
![Rachel]()
Rachel A. Sent on 03/13/2023Sunset Paradise Venue
Hands down the best place to have your wedding in the Florida Keys! Jill and her team know exactly what they're doing at Islamorada Fish Company. My husband and I planned our entire wedding from PA through emails and phone calls and we never had to worry about things not getting done or questions not being answered. We had so many guests compliment how delicious the food during cocktail hour and dinner was. The bar service was amazing! The selection of beers, wines, and spirits was more than we've ever seen at any other wedding we've attended. The sunset was absolutely breathtaking and will always be one of the best highlights of our special day. We have no regrets booking our wedding at IFC and would do it all over again!!
Are you interested?
Are you interested?