The Cake Girl Reviews
Reviews
We're all about trust. Our community relies on honest reviews to help you make those big decisions with ease.
5.0 out of 5 rating
![WeddingWire Couples' Choice Awards 2024 Winner]()
5.0 out of 5 rating
60 Reviews
99% recommend it
-
Felicia P. Sent on 08/27/2024
Baby Shower Delight
When I tell you the cake and cupcakes they made for my daughter’s baby shower were amazing trust me they were! Every guest wanted to know who made them and with pride I Sade The Cake Girl. Thank you so much for making her day just a little bit special with your beautiful cake. -
-
Karen L. Sent on 06/28/2024
The Cake Girl
The Cake Girl delivered a beautiful and delicious wedding cake. I requested service from The Cake Girl two weeks before my wedding with very specific design specs. No time for a tasting or an in person collaboration on design. Kirby was kind and patient and delivered a design that was spot on. There were many flavor options, but the almond flavored cake with the Dulce de Leche buttercream was absolutely divine. Even my guest are planning on sharing this tasting again on our anniversary. It was just that good! What made my experience even more special was the delivery by Kirby himself. Chef's Kiss to The Cake Girl Team! -
-
![Olivia]()
Olivia A. Sent on 03/07/2024Best grooms cake design!!
The cake girl team did an amazing job with the green cake and wedding cake!! The cake itself tasted great, very moist, and still it was delicious after a week. It is definitely worth the money, you’re paying for amazing quality. -
-
![Danielle]()
Danielle P. Sent on 03/16/2024Excellent and delicious!!
From the first interaction until cake pick-up, this was an excellent experience. They are professional and our cake was perfect and delicious! -
-
![S B]()
S B Sent on 03/05/2024Fantastic custom wedding cake
The Cake Girl did our custom wedding cake, which we wanted to recognize our thirteen (13!) years of dating/engagement plus the groom's penchant for metal. They did a fantastic job - the cake was both beautiful and delicious! -
-
Kim B. Sent on 02/17/2024
The Only Place to Make & Design Your Wedding Cake
This was not my first experience with The Cake Girl! This was my 3rd! Very Professional! The process was seamless and stress free! Most importantly, she listened to what we wanted and designed the most beautiful wedding cake for our special day! The cake was delicious! The Cake Girl has earned my business for a lifetime!! -
-
![Kristen]()
Kristen S. Sent on 02/23/2024100% Recommend
OMG! The cake girl is the most perfect team! Kirby runs things in the store and on the customer service/communication side while his wife prepares the most magical cakes! Kirby is so responsive and was so helpful in the design/size choosing process. They are so professional and the cake turned out so beautiful! My husband Taylor and I came 6 months early to visit and do a tasting. The cake was not only beautiful, but DELICIOUS! The delivery was prompt and they even helped place my cake cluster flowers on the cake for me with the planner when they got there! We were not able to save the top tier of our cake due to so many guests, however we were able to order custom cake jars later that were exact replicas of the four layers of our wedding cake to freeze. I cannot wait to try them out in a year from now!! 100% recommend the cake girl for your wedding day!!! -
Sherra K. Sent on 05/13/2024
Beyond Beautiful
I gave The Cake Girl Team ideas that we were looking at for our daughter and son in laws wedding cake, and it turned out better than we could have ever expected. Not only was the cake beautiful but one of the most delicious cakes we have ever eaten. I cannot recommend them enough! -
-
![Gabby]()
Gabby C. Sent on 12/04/2023Exactly what we asked for
Our wedding cake looked absolutely gorgeous and tasted incredible! Exactly what we wanted! -
Judy H. Sent on 12/10/2023
Awesome wedding cake !
The Cake Girl customized our cake to our needs. Kirby and team worked with us on style and flavors. Even allowing us to customize each layer - including carrot cake for the groom. The cake was moist and delicious - lots of compliments from our guests. The cake was amazing ! Thanks to Cake Girl !!! -
-
Tracy M. Sent on 10/17/2023
Beautiful and delicious!
The cake was absolutely gorgeous and exactly what I envisioned and it tasted amazing also! -
-
![Kiera]()
Kiera H. Sent on 10/30/2023Perfect for wedding!
I worked with The Cake Girl to provide my wedding cake and cupcakes. They were wonderful to work with - very patient, kind, responsive and accommodating. The cake and cupcakes were beautiful, and of course delicious. One of the more amazing parts is you can request a tasting by mail! This was extremely helpful as we were planning our wedding from an entirely different state. Highly recommend! -
-
![Janet]()
Janet B. Sent on 07/18/2023Wedding cake
The Cake Girl did an amazing job. Sent us samples, was able to design our cake with pictures. We were out of state. I highly recommend them. The price was very reasonable. -
-
![Tanya]()
Tanya Sent on 08/14/2023Beautiful work
The Cake Girl Team did absolutely amazing job on my wedding cupcake tower.
Highly recommend them:) -
-
![S Sleigher]()
S Sleigher Sent on 05/20/2023Best Wedding Cake Ever!
Our Wedding Cake was perfection! The process to make our cake was so easy. The staff was super responsive to all communications. It seems like The Cake Girl and her staff takes great care in what they do. The cake was beautiful. It was exactly as described. All of our guests loved it. One of our friends said it was the best wedding cake they ever had. I loved the ease of picking up a sample cake pack and picking out our flavors and design. The option to include cookie butter as your filling is a must. It left all of our guests guessing what the delicious filling was haha. The desserts that I added on were excellent too. I always wanted to have a dessert platter with a cake. If you want a cake for any event, but especially your wedding. This is the place to go! -
-
Dennis T. Sent on 04/25/2023
Converted Cake Lovers Now!
We are not huge cake people, but The Cake Girl definitely changed our minds! We hired The Cake Girl based on a recommendation from our wedding planner and we were not disappointed. Our only request was to have cupcakes and cake pops for our guest and the rest we left to them...flavors, design, etc. The end product was awesome and more than we could have imagined! The flavors were so bold and delicious that it left our guests raving about the cupcakes and cake pops. The design of our cake was simple but elegant. We loved it! I highly recommend using The Cake Girl for your wedding or any party that you are having cake. -
-
![Jenna]()
Jenna S. Sent on 01/22/2023Absolutely delicious
We did the at home taste testing and the girls were wonderful when we went in to the store. They made the process simple, and gave me plenty of options to choose from. All of the cakes we sampled were wonderful. on our wedding day everything turned out beautiful. We had a cake, variety of cupcakes and brownies for our wedding, by the end of the night there was almost nothing left because everyone loved them. They were also great about letting me make a few changes later on to accommodate some guest dietary restrictions. We were extremely happy with the outcome. -
-
![Terra]()
Terra H. Sent on 12/01/2022Big Cake - Small Cake, Who's to Say?
The custom cake process was efficient. I asked for a MUCH smaller cake, but received a cake for the entire floor of my hotel. I specifically requested a smaller cake as we had no guests. It truly was just a beach ceremony for us. I was stunned when I picked it up. HOWEVER, who can complain when the cake was as beautiful and decadent as shown? We wound up giving the bottom buttercream and raspberry cake to the staff at the hotel. Hope they enjoyed. We saved the top for our anniversary. I ordered the topper and floral pics from Etsy.
Will definitely order again for my daughter's birthday. (Much smaller.) -
-
Antonette B. Sent on 12/30/2022
Great customer service. Highly recommend!
Our dream wedding was on 11.11.22. I always believe that customer service goes a long way. The customer service we received from Kirby made my wife and I choose The Cake Girl on our very first cake tasting visit. The moment my wife and I walked in, Kirby was excited to help us. He brought our wedding cake vision to life. The two most important factors for us were that we didn't go over our cake budget and Kirby made us feel comfortable, being that we are a same sex couple. From design to delivery, he executed everything with 100% customer satisfaction. We thank him again
for his help in designing and creating our dream wedding cake.
Our cake: We chose a 3 tier with delectable layers of rum cake with dulce de leche and cream cheese icing and chocolate cake with cookies and cream cream cheese icing. Our guests raved about how good our cake tasted. -
-
![Betsy]()
Betsy E. Sent on 01/03/2023Best cake bakery in both design and taste!
Cannot say enough good things about the entire Cake Girl team!!! Kirby and rest of staff were wonderful to work with from start to finish. We had an idea in mind of the artistic wedding cake we wanted, and with Kirby's guidance along the way it came out even better than anything we could have imagined. Equally, Cake Girl blew our "Goon Squad" themed groom's cake out of the water too! So much so, that sports radio show hosts Pat Donovan & Aaron Jacobson of the "Pat & Aaron Show" crashed our wedding reception to see firsthand... also one of the top wedding highlights for my husband! Not only did we have multiple guests tell us the cakes were best they've ever seen, but there was no wedding cake leftover either (yes, our guests ate every last bite)... we strongly recommend the mocha cream cheese filling! Thanks Cake Girl for making both our wedding and groom's cakes a huge hit, both in design and taste, and thereby helping add to our Best Day yet! We'll definitely be returning customers for all special occasions ahead! -
