Anniversary Cake - Do or Ditch?

We're going to try to do it but I wouldn't be upset if it didn't happen.

Gross no. We are saving the top of the cake for after the honeymoon. But for our anniversary- i would rather have a fresh cake

Ditch. We have no plans to do this. I've heard no matter how carefully you store it, it's terrible. Also, I don't want a tier of cake in my freezer for a year, lol.

Yuck, I am a baker and I always give my customers a fresh 6" anniversary cake that matches the one at their wedding, it's part of their package.

We’ll buy a new tier to eat, no year old cake for us 😂

We are going with a simple Wedding cake that has two tiers the top u always freeze. And we are going to have a grooms cake.

View Quoted Comment Yall need to get them at ur local bakery. I always use Publix or Ingles. They make the best. Maybe go to a cake Tasting for different flavors so you can enjoy.

Ditch! We aren't having cake really. Donuts for us!

View Quoted Comment You will be surprised. This is my 2nd Wedding in 18 yrs. We took the top and wrapped it in wax paper and then plastic wrap then foil. 1 yr Anniversary we took it out and it was Delicious as the day we got married.

Passing on stale cake. We figured we could always buy a small cake for the occasion when it comes.

No, our only "cake" will be one small tier for the cake cutting. After that, there won't be anything left to save. We'll probably get a completely fresh cake for our anniversary. No stale cake.

Well all depends ....if it a fruit cake then yes because that will hold up one year later but any other ...nah skip

Ditching this one. We are having a DW and don't want to try and figure out a way to bring it back

View Quoted Comment Oh, I will absolutely do a cake tasting or 2.... because I freaking love cake xD. But we’re not going to buy any. I’m making cupcakes cause I can make the 120 I’d need for under $100, and I enjoy baking

View Quoted Comment That's great.

Ditch. We're not even having a wedding cake, but doing 2 giant french macaron towers instead. Macarons can be frozen, but not for that long.

Oh heck no!!! Fiance and I try to eat mainly freshly baked goods. This wouldn't work for us. Stale cake: no!

I really want to do one year anniversary cake and freeze our top bit with a destination wedding with honeymoon following and customs I don’t think it will be possible to bring it home. 😢

We didn’t keep our cake to eat on our anniversary. However we did get a small cake in the same flavors and from the same bakery as our wedding cake. It was delicious.

Doing, although against my will. My ILs absolutely INSISTED on taking the top tier and preserving it for us. Apparently MIL found instructions online and followed them to the letter. So, we’ll see what it’s like in November.