Skip to main content

Post content has been hidden

To unblock this content, please click here

Berta
Just Said Yes October 2021

Boyfriend didn’t propose and I’m disappointed

Berta, on December 26, 2019 at 6:53 AM

Posted in Family and Relationships 49

Sorry if I posted this on the wrong thread, but it’s the only place I can find posts similar to my situation. My boyfriend and I have been together for 3 years we are 25. I have expressed to him that I would love to have kids before I’m 28-29. But that I would also like to be married before I have...

Sorry if I posted this on the wrong thread, but it’s the only place I can find posts similar to my situation.


My boyfriend and I have been together for 3 years we are 25. I have expressed to him that I would love to have kids before I’m 28-29. But that I would also like to be married before I have children. He has said we’re on the same page, but he also says that he would rather have kids when we’re 29-30. None the less the last time we talked I expressed that I just wasn’t sure if we wanted the same things out of life, or rather we both want marriage and children just not at the same times. He asked me to rest assured that those things will happen for us and soon because he has a “plan” for his proposal. He’s been asking me about rings and our future an awful lot so I was expecting it to happen soon—like he said.

After that talk I expected maybe he was proposing on Christmas—well turns out that he didn’t—and I’ve been really sad. I’m worried that I’m going to stay in this relationship hoping that one day he will do the things he’s said—but what if he never does? At what point do I say that I’m being lead on?

For christmas the only gift he got my was a trip trip to my favorite place—Oregon! He said he knew it’s my favorite city and got flight insurance to cancel so we can decide when we’re going! He’s thinking February or March. I got a slight glimmer of hope that MAYBE he will propose on the trip? But again what if he doesn’t?

My question is—should I hold out for the trip or should I just realize this relationship might not ever go the way I want? I love him with everything I have but if three years isn’t long enough for you to decide what you want I don’t want to keep wasting my time with someone who doesn’t know what they want when I could find someone whose future plans look more like my own. I feel like I’m a relationship it should be both of us making compromises but it feels like on this one I just have to sit back and he gets to plan our future—all of the things I’ve expressed don’t matter because to him—he wants to have kids later in life and he wants to be married later so that’s what we have to do. I don’t think it should be that way.

I’m not trying to rush things, but I feel like my future is in his hands and I don’t think he realizes the amount of time it take to plan a wedding/book a venue. I’m not sure how to feel. I feel somewhat impatient. Do I have a conversation and express how I feel? But then I feel like if he is proposing on our trip I will feel like a brat from being upset that it didn’t happen on Christmas. Please help I have so many feelings and I’m not sure what to do lol

Any advice welcome!


49 Comments

  • Megan
    Dedicated September 2020
    Megan ·
    • Flag
    • Hide content

    Ask HIM! I was in the same situation... We had been together 3 years and I was 26, I am 27 now... I had him a knife made didn't cost much 25 bucks or so with his name engraved on the handle and" marry me? " engraved on the blade. Either way you will have your answer. Is it engrained in us since birth to want the man to propose? yes. Can we do our own thing? Also, yes... youtube women proposing to their men... I did it made me brave. Smiley smile Keep in mind sometimes it takes a while for it to sink in. He is just now buying me a ring I will get on the new year and we were engaged nearly a year ago... Sometimes it takes patience, but regardless you need to speak to him first, if you haven't already if you can't be open and honest with him it may be time to move on. Unfortunately, men are not mind readers and you will have to be as literal as possible when telling him your needs and desires. Best of luck!

    • Reply
  • Ellen
    Dedicated September 2020
    Ellen ·
    • Flag
    • Hide content
    View Quoted Comment
    I just turned 38, and I’m getting married in May. I can tell you, as someone who felt everyone else was getting the things in their 20s, I WOULD NOT CHANGE A DAMN THING. Some of those couples are happy, some are divorced - but I know without hesitation that I’m marry the man I’ve wished for my whole life, and I got to experience life the way I wanted before I met him.


    Throw your timeline away, you are SO YOUNG. Take a step back, do you want to marry him or marry a timeline? There is no rush, and life always works out. When you do get engaged, you want to know your partner is all in, not that he felt rushed and had to propose simply to make you happy. Best of luck.
    • Reply
  • Kelly
    Dedicated September 2020
    Kelly ·
    • Flag
    • Hide content
    First off you are young and have plenty of time. He may want the proposal to be more private and that’s why he didn’t do it at Christmas. I also would phrase a trip as “only”... seems like a pretty nice gift... it seems like that may be his idea for the proposal if he knows how much you like it. Maybe if it doesn’t happen on the trip just bring it up again more seriously. Some men need an ultimatum or they will just keep going on how things are because they were content. I flat out told my fiancé (prior to being engaged) that if he didn’t propose to me by the end of 2019 I would propose to him which he didn’t like the idea of at all since he’s more traditional in the sense of the man asking the woman. I am older than you (will be 29 in June) so having kids is my main motivation to “s—t or get off the pot”. Either way he clearly loves you and is planning this special trip... I would wait till then and if nothing happens revisit the topic.
    • Reply
  • Jessica
    Dedicated March 2025
    Jessica ·
    • Flag
    • Hide content
    I didn’t read the whole thread ,but my husband says that a man like the element of surprise for an engagement. So he’s probably finding a time when I least expect it. The more you ask the more he may put it off so it has the element of surprise.
    • Reply
  • Amir
    Just Said Yes June 2020
    Amir ·
    • Flag
    • Hide content
    I do not want my own Children... I own FurKIDS instead! My Boyfriend is going back to India and I wanted to raise his Daughter with him but he just kept knocking his Baby Cousin and so I moved to Portland away from the Drama...
    I need to find something else to do now as my Cooking Dream was put on Hold, thank you Cora Virus!!! Anyway my Mom and I now live in Port-land happily. So if you want to come up here, e-mail me and we can fly up together to Vegas!

    Sincerely, Michelle
    • Reply
  • Martha
    Devoted February 2024
    Martha ·
    • Flag
    • Hide content

    I understand you, I have been where you and and I know its a hard wait. Like pp has said do you want to restart anew with someone else in the hope that they meet your deadline? If you love him and you see your future with him give him a bit more time. I had a date set in my head about my proposal it was supposed to have been at the last concert of my favorite band as it was their farewell tour, it did not happen, I mourned the loss of my favorite band and my dead dream of that proposal. It was soul crushing but after a bit I realized that perhaps my boyfriend wanted it to be a special moment for us. I decided to give us more time, and to enjoy the moment we have in between. Eventually it happened and it was the best I could hope for, even with no official witnesses around it was perfect, its a moment we will always have to ourselves, we have all the future leap years to remind us.I'm sure it will happen for you too, I hope its a surprise and catches you off guard.

    • Reply
  • Shirley
    Expert November 2020
    Shirley ·
    • Flag
    • Hide content
    First, I think timing is a make-or-break thing even in good relationships. Timing does matter, and I think you are right to be thinking about it. I don't think you're too young to think about it, nor are your thoughts wrong about how long one should date before being married. That said, if you guys aren't on the same page on timing, it could spell the end of the relationship, so think long and hard about it.


    I have a few friends with a story similar to this: Girl dates guy for 2 years. Girl moves in with guy, expects proposal in a year but never mentions it. Girl mentions marriage during 2nd year of living together, and guy says he isn't ready. She mentions it the 3rd year. Then the 4th. Guy says he will ask one day. Eventually, girl leaves. She doesn't give an ultimatum, she just leaves. In all scenarios in my experience, the guy does not chase her. He just didn't want to be married. Almost all the girls are now happily married to someone else.
    I think it is possible that he plans to propose on the trip, so I would wait. If it doesn't happen, have another discussion. This time, instead of sharing your timeline, ask him what he wants and why. Collect notes. Take some time to consider and address his fears: financial readiness, his ability to be a good father, his worries that he didn't fully experience his youth, a set career goal. Think about which fears are normal and can be talked through (fear of parenting) and which are immovable obstacles (career goals). If there are any immovable obstacles, you need to think about whether or not you want to wait around for him to hit certain goals or thresholds (which he may not hit for another 10 years or he may increase along the way).
    I recommended you not wait forever because you love him. Of course you love him. But there are many guys you could love. You want a man who wants to commit and to start a family, and that is important. I think you should set a defined period of time you will wait for yourself (don't share with him) and continue to reiterate yo him your interest to be married and start a family. If he doesn't propose in your time frame, leave. He may come find you and propose. Or he may not and you can go meet someone whose goals are more aligned with yours.
    • Reply
  • Alyssa
    Super December 2021
    Alyssa ·
    • Flag
    • Hide content
    I know this thread is old, but since it’s trending again, here’s my 2 cents: I learned years ago not to worry about a timeline for life. I used to have one and it went out the window. If I would have pressed my luck, I never would have moved away from a crappy town, gone to grad school and met my now husband. I would have married someone who was completely wrong for me because I thought I had to be married by 25. I’m so glad I lived up the last part of my 20s, I don’t regret one second.
    • Reply
  • J
    Jada ·
    • Flag
    • Hide content
    I know that you posted this a few years back, but I'm curious to know what has happened. Hoping for the best for you
    • Reply

You voted for . Add a comment 👇

×
WeddingWire celebrates love ...and so does everyone on our site! Learn more

Groups

WeddingWire article topics