Confused about dresses?

Hi all! We went shopping for dresses for the first time today! Eek!! I loved it. The first dress I tried on was the all white, and I thought it was the one I wanted. I loved it on me but I’m not sure it gave me the feeling I thought it would. The third one I tried on was the blush one (everyone loved it) which would be ordered in white for me. everyone absolutely loved it but I’m not sure I was fully convinced. Of the two I think I might like the first one better. I also want to try on some other styles, so we’re going back next weekend. Any thoughts on which looks better?