Skip to main content

Post content has been hidden

To unblock this content, please click here

Brittany
Savvy July 2019

Engagement Ring change

Brittany, on December 18, 2018 at 10:22 AM Posted in Wedding Attire 0 14
So my Fiancé proposed to me with this 3/4 carat ring (first 2 pictures) and it was designed how I explained to him however wasn’t quite what I was expecting and due to the design I would have to get a curved wedding band (I wanted a straight and sparkly one) After some talk and unfortunately a few arguments 😢 we agreed to go back to the jewelers and see what we could do! They had 25-40% off sale and my FH agreed we could totally swap in the first ring for a new ring if I so choose. Now the ring he modeled after was an $8,000 ring and I shouldn’t have even expected him to pay that much when he clearly told me he couldn’t! So he tried to make it work the best way he could by getting me the look a like (first two pictures). I tried to be happy with it and in my heart I was trying so hard to like it but I just didn’t ....so he agreeed to come with me to the store and see what could be done. When we went back to Kays we had 2 options (get the ring I loved and pay the balance or find another ring in our budget) —-if we decided to get the original $8000 1 carat Tolkowsky ring (now on sale) we would still have to pay an additional $3,000 pay off for it after the exchange and he was very adamant all week on not paying extra but once we were in the store he saw how much I loved it and he agreed we could do it. BUT I decided not to put that financial burden on us despite him finally agreeing, I asked to see rings in our budget. We found this ring (3rd/4th ring picture) it’s a 0.5 carat double halo pave 14k white gold ring and we’re able to do an even exchange ring swap only paying $150 for the lifetime warranty! We were both thrilled, I’m so in love with my new ring- he is so happy as well that the ring looks better and our parents are Also happy and pleased with the swap feeling the 2nd ring is more elegant. Now that the ring issue got resolved .....Here is the problem now...... we posted a picture on our engagement day of the first ring (cute and petite - first 2 photos) and now for our engagement photos we will have the newer bigger ring and I am concerned about what others might think about this. Getting or wanting a bigger ring is always shamed on and frowned upon and I know I shouldn’t care what people think .. my FH and immediate family were only super supportive and happy with our decision and I don’t want to care what others would think, but I do...... any advice ladies on the posting of the new ring and have any of you changed the e-ring before the wedding ?


Engagement Ring change 1

Engagement Ring change 2

Engagement Ring change 3

Engagement Ring change 4

14 Comments

Latest activity by Jayla, on December 18, 2018 at 5:21 PM
  • Nemo
    Master August 2018
    Nemo ·
    • Flag
    • Hide content

    Honestly, very few people are even going to notice. So I wouldn't worry about it! It isn't their business anyway.

    • Reply
  • Caytlyn
    Legend November 2019
    Caytlyn ·
    • Flag
    • Hide content

    You decided that you were unhappy with the ring that your fiance proposed to you with and made him exchange it. You deal with the repercussions. I highly doubt anyone will notice and/or say anything anyway.

    • Reply
  • Gen
    Champion June 2019
    Gen ·
    • Flag
    • Hide content
    I love this! Your new one is so similar to the original but it’s like an “upgrade” lol. Since they are so similar I don’t even think people will notice. But also, it’s not that weird to get a new engagement ring. My FH’s friend proposed to his now-wife with a MASSIVE 2-carat diamond that he spent literally his entire life’s savings on (he wanted to show her how valuable she was to him lol). She said that, while she appreciated the sentiment, she didn’t feel good about wearing his life’s savings on her finger. They exchanged it for a similar style, but about 1 carat now. There were pictures of both rings on their social media and honestly I didn’t think twice about the fact that they were different until we saw them and they told us the story and then I was like “oh yeah, those WERE different rings.”

    I kind of feel silly since I’ll have pictures with 3 different ones... the one my FH proposed with (and we posted pictures of that), the one I wore for our official engagement photos 6 months later, and the one I have now that will be in our wedding photos. Original ring was cubic zirconia (FH wanted a “fake” ring to propose with so I could help pick out my own), second ring was one we picked out but the jeweler messed up the sizing so we had to return it months later (loooong story) and now I finally have the ring that I’ll (hopefully) have forever lol. All 3 of mine looked sooo different. A couple people have commented (“wait, that looks different than the one you had before”) and I just laugh and roll my eyes and I’m like “yeah, we exchanged it, long story.” And that’s that. It’s not a huge deal. (Pics are my 3 rings in order lol)

    Engagement Ring change 5

    Engagement Ring change 6

    Engagement Ring change 7
    • Reply
  • PurdyAikey
    Super January 2019
    PurdyAikey ·
    • Flag
    • Hide content

    Honestly, I wouldn't notice especially if the pictures aren't right next to each other. If someone does, I wouldn't worry about it. Just say you exchanged it, and leave it at that.

    • Reply
  • Brittany
    Savvy July 2019
    Brittany ·
    • Flag
    • Hide content
    View Quoted Comment
    Wow thank you for sharing this... this helped a lot to know I’m not the only one and your right .. seeing those different pictures I wouldn’t spend much time wondering why or if you swapped rings! They all look nice and it’s your choice!! Thank you for this feedback!
    • Reply
  • Brittany
    Savvy July 2019
    Brittany ·
    • Flag
    • Hide content
    View Quoted Comment
    You’re absolutely right! Thank you!
    • Reply
  • Brittany
    Savvy July 2019
    Brittany ·
    • Flag
    • Hide content
    View Quoted Comment
    And that’s the main point! It’s no one’s business but ours and we are both very happy with our decision! Thank you!
    • Reply
  • Gen
    Champion June 2019
    Gen ·
    • Flag
    • Hide content
    View Quoted Comment
    No problem! Right, like even though mine are all very different when you actually look at them and think about it, seriously the majority of people that will see your pictures wouldn’t even think twice about it 😂 ESPECIALLY because yours are so similar, I doubt anyone will notice unless looking for the difference
    • Reply
  • BrandiWeds18
    VIP May 2019
    BrandiWeds18 ·
    • Flag
    • Hide content

    Actually this weekend we went to Zales where my ring was purchased and we talked upgrades. I didn't find one i liked better so we didn't do it. We mainly went so we could size his finger for me to purchase his ring next month. But he said i could upgrade since we had postponed the wedding and he promised an upgrade at some point. I definitely love the fact that i can do an even or "nearly" even trade for lifetime.

    • Reply
  • Brittany
    Savvy July 2019
    Brittany ·
    • Flag
    • Hide content
    View Quoted Comment
    The even exchange was the icing on the cake .. we were expecting to pay maybe at least $1000 as my first ring was definitely a lower quality diamond and band but with the 25-40% off sale on rings in the store it worked out perfectly! I highly suggesting doing your upgrade during a sale period !
    • Reply
  • Megan
    Super May 2019
    Megan ·
    • Flag
    • Hide content

    Honestly, I don't think people on social media pay THAT much attention to noticing your ring is different in different postings, especially if they are days, weeks, months apart. If you're that worried about it, you don't have to post any up close pictures of your new ring. If you decide to, and someone does comment, you can choose to ignore them or you can provide a short, simple answer..."we decided to exchange the original"

    • Reply
  • HayMrsO
    Master October 2018
    HayMrsO ·
    • Flag
    • Hide content

    Congratulations on getting a ring that you love!

    I really don't think that people will notice. And if they do, so what! That will be people just being petty. Your ring is beautiful!

    • Reply
  • Jane
    Expert May 2019
    Jane ·
    • Flag
    • Hide content

    I would never comment on someone changing their ring... high chances are that I wouldn't even notice to start with !

    Don't stress, your finger, your ring, your couple.


    Ps... It's lovely

    • Reply
  • Jayla
    Champion October 2025
    Jayla ·
    • Flag
    • Hide content

    Hey Brittany!! First of all both rings are gorgeous!! I love what you've upgraded to and think it's even more stunning, I'm glad you were able to find what you really wanted. Honestly, I don't think people will notice a difference unless you post the pictures together. Don't worry about it and only address it if you want to or if someone mentions it, do whatever you feel most comfortable with!

    • Reply

You voted for . Add a comment 👇

×

Related articles

WeddingWire celebrates love ...and so does everyone on our site! Learn more

Groups

WeddingWire article topics