Skip to main content

Post content has been hidden

To unblock this content, please click here

--------
Just Said Yes October 2021

Financial help & weird family dynamics

--------, on August 28, 2020 at 1:50 PM

Posted in Planning 25

Edit: Yikes, the comment section on this forum is rough, huh? Lol - to clarify, we don't plan on ASKING for the help. That's 100% not our style and it's never something we'd expect. HOWEVER, we WOULD like to know at what point do parents typically offer that sort of thing. If they never bring it...

Edit: Yikes, the comment section on this forum is rough, huh? Lol - to clarify, we don't plan on ASKING for the help. That's 100% not our style and it's never something we'd expect. HOWEVER, we WOULD like to know at what point do parents typically offer that sort of thing. If they never bring it up, we would NEVER in a million years ask. We just need to know for example, if they haven't said anything within the next 2 months, do we decide "okay, we have $10k, let's work with it"? Or how did that discussion go with anyone else in a similar situation?


Hi all! First time poster here looking for some budget advice relating to unusual family dynamics. My fiancé and I just got engaged 2 weeks ago. We’re both really excited to start planning but wanted to take a few weeks to relax and just celebrate being engaged first. But of course – I can’t help myself and have been doing tons of research on venues anyway. I knew weddings were expensive but I guess I never realized HOW expensive. We live in the suburbs of Chicago and are expecting between 125-150 guests and I can’t seem to find a venue that would cost less than $10k (food, drinks, ceremony, etc. included). We’d love to pay on our own but can only afford between $10-$15k without going into debt (this would have to include venue, photography, DJ, dress, etc.) so we’re considering asking for help but not sure HOW to do it given some weird family dynamics.

Both of our moms as well as my dad would give us the world but aren’t in a place where they could help financially so we don’t even want to ask. His dad and step-mom on the other hand do VERY well for themselves. When my fiancé’s grandma passed away 2 years ago, they sold her house and his dad divided what would have been his portion of the money between my fiancé and his sister but specifically insisted we save it for big things like a down payment on a house or a car (which is 100% what we intend to do with it and don’t want to use it for the wedding). His sister seems to think he didn’t even mention weddings because it goes without saying that he would help. BUT he’s always been very traditional and I’m worried he might just expect to pay for his daughter’s wedding but not his son’s.

The part that worries me here is that for a few years, my fiancé and his dad had a very rocky relationship. When his parents divorced, his dad moved to Florida, quickly married his new wife and moved in his step-daughter, leaving my fiancé and his sister to feel sort of left behind. They actually went a few years without talking and only over the last 2 years have been working hard to repair their relationship. I know that if we were to get married and didn’t have financial help and then a couple years from now his step-sister and her boyfriend were to get married and his dad helped, it would throw a HUGE wrench into their relationship. He feels like if his dad would pay for his step-son, in-law’s wedding but not his own son’s, it would say a lot. And I can’t really disagree.

Anyway - we got engaged the day before we went on a 5 day vacation with them, his sister, step-sister and her boyfriend and kind of figured at some point they would bring up the wedding and that they’d want to financially help but that never happened. His step-mom did mention a few times to let her know when we start planning but I couldn’t tell if that was more of a “we need a date so we can make sure we’re available” since they live in Florida and are both busy people OR a “once you have a better idea of timing, we can talk finances”.

So my question is, how do you go about asking for help? We likely won’t see them in person until closer to Christmas (we’d like to have the venue booked by Oct.) so it would have to be via phone call. I’m thinking we call/message them (they’re super busy people and always prefer texts but this feels like more of a call convo) and let them know we’re thinking of an Oct 2021 time frame (Covid dependent, obviously) but final date depends on the venue and we’re still trying to determine our budget and what we can afford. Hopefully this will give a big enough hint and they’ll bring up whether or not they plan on helping.

I know we should just come straight out and ask but it feels SO weird to do that with in-law’s that I’m not close with and it feels weird for my fiancé since he’s still in the process of repairing that relationship and doesn’t want it to feel like he’s using them for money (not that we have any inclination that they’d ever think that).

Any advice from anyone who has been in a similar situation (or just someone who is good at advice lol) would be really helpful! Thanks Smiley smile

25 Comments

  • Mrs.a
    Master October 2021
    Mrs.a ·
    • Flag
    • Hide content

    I honestly don’t think anyone was being harsh, just sharing honest opinions and feedback tbh. You did state at the end of your post “So my question is, how do you go about asking for help?“ after you talk about the expense of things and wedding costing so much.

    I guess the question is, what kind of help are you asking for? Help with planning? Picking out things? DIY? Or Money/paying for things?

    Because if you aren’t looking for help paying for things, there are a lot of options and people here are willing to help with advice, tools, and resources to help guide and direct you. If you’d like help paying for things and your family members aren’t willing or able to do so, then there are options for you to figure that part out as well. Financing, which I wouldn’t recommend. Saving until you can reasonably afford to have the wedding you desire. Scaling back on things, prioritizing and investing on what’s most important. I think creating a budget and a list of priorities is a good start. You can start to plan how much each option costs and how much you can possibly afford. I certainly wouldn’t go booking venues or vendors until you have a budget and a goal to have the money you need in order to afford your wedding.

    I hope this helps Smiley smile

    • Reply
  • H
    Devoted August 2023
    Hhh ·
    • Flag
    • Hide content
    I have a slightly different opinion in that they are family and wedding costs and expectations are going to come up at some point, so it is better to talk finances sooner than later.
    After we got engaged, FH made a list of our priorities for the wedding. We shared these with our families to set clear expectations because we knew we would be covering the full cost ourselves (his family is not in the position to help and I made an agreement with mine years ago that they would help with college in place of a wedding). Later when they suggested venues and guests, we just went back to the fact that it wasn’t our priority and didn’t fit our budget. So when they decided that upgrading to our dream venue, where the extended family could stay together onsite for the weekend, was their priority, they offered to pick up the difference in price (we were shocked!)
    So yes, asking for a large sum of money to put in the ambiguous pot of “wedding budget” is not a good approach. However, they will be more likely to want to contribute if it is for a specific item that makes the day extra special. Worst case, by being forthcoming initially on what the wedding you can afford looks like, you will align their (and your!) expectations for the day - not to mention have a better position to politely decline their expensive suggestions later in the planning process.
    • Reply
  • C
    Savvy September 2021
    Cherie ·
    • Flag
    • Hide content
    The mans parents are supposed to pay for the rehearsal dinner, transportation and something else. Look it up what do grooms parents typically pay. It doesn’t mean they will pay but it does mean I wouldn’t include them in many things they would just be guests
    • Reply
  • A
    Super September 2020
    Alli ·
    • Flag
    • Hide content
    If you don’t have the money, don’t plan a wedding relying on hopes of getting money... my parents notified us within two weeks of our engagement, but his parents never offered anything. So it’s hard to say you’ll have $20K but $5K is coming from a parent, etc. Best wishes ❤️
    • Reply
  • M
    VIP January 2019
    Maggie ·
    • Flag
    • Hide content
    View Quoted Comment

    Nope, there are no "supposed tos". In the past, in some places, has it been the custom that the groom's family paid for the rehearsal dinner? Yes. Not sure about "transportation and something else" but no doubt that is someone's custom somewhere. But it's not, like, a universal law, any more than it's a universal law that the bride's family is supposed to pay for everything else.

    Of course there is nothing wrong with any family member offering to pay for things, but relying on spending people's money just because "it's tradition!" is a good way to get hurt feelings and damaged relationships. There are a hundred good reasons that someone wouldn't offer the gift of money and an equal number why it might be wise to decline the offer. The whole of wedding planning goes so much smoother if expectations are left at the door.

    • Reply

You voted for . Add a comment 👇

×
WeddingWire celebrates love ...and so does everyone on our site! Learn more

Groups

WeddingWire article topics