I never liked the idea of the garter toss. I don't need my grandmother seeing anybody up my skirt, married or not. We just weren't going to do it, until I thought of a cool alternative! I'm going to get a little black book for FH to toss instead. Inside, instead of having exes numbers and stuff (which would kind of bother me, going through and filling it out haha) all it will say is "See the best man" (FH's best friend and major ladies man). I think it would be particularly funny if BM caught it.
Are you doing a garter toss? If not, have you thought of an alternative?