Skip to main content

Post content has been hidden

To unblock this content, please click here

M
Beginner March 2025

Guest list dispute/ probably too long of a rant🙃

Mads, on January 9, 2024 at 9:45 PM

Posted in Planning 26

Background — both my fiancé and I come from large family’s I have 86 relatives over the age of 18 and my finances family is a little bit larger. We both agreed we wanted a small wedding and want to keep it closer to 15,000$. We have agreed upon a 75-100 person headcount. My fiancé has been asked...
Background — both my fiancé and I come from large family’s I have 86 relatives over the age of 18 and my finances family is a little bit larger. We both agreed we wanted a small wedding and want to keep it closer to 15,000$. We have agreed upon a 75-100 person headcount.


My fiancé has been asked several times to fill out his family headcount. Today when discussing he said he did not want to cut out any cousins. More than half of his cousins I have not met and he does not keep in touch with outside of a family event every few years. None of them have reached out since we’ve been engaged although it was announced in their family groupchat. I told him I do not want anyone at our wedding that I do not know or that we do not see more than once a year. He is extremely upset and said that he doesn’t know if he can make cuts. Am I wrong for my view and expectations on who is invited to our wedding?
I also am struggling cause he has a friend who I do not like who he wants to come. This person has made it clear he doesn’t like me, he owes my fiancé money, and only wants to visit when my fiancé will use his season tickets to take him to football games. My fiancé texted him that he was proposing and he never responded. When my fiancé called him to tell him I said yes he didn’t even say congratulations he just talked about how he was going to be the best man. He word for word said “I’m not going to contribute to anything financially to be your best man or help plan anything but I do expect to be the person standing next to you on the day” this is not someone I want in my life let alone at my wedding.
It’s starting to get really frustrating because our wedding is not a family reunion and he has been asked for over a week to get a list together. He also wants me to start planning now so we can plan as I just moved out of state and we are buying a house here an he is moving here later this year so we want to get married right after and also have a tight bonus with two mortgages and a wedding.
I’m probably just stressed but it’s feeling like this isn’t about us anymore and is just causing flights. I’m becoming more and more stressed about it and feel like I don’t really have support. I have him my expectation that he needs to help with at least 50% of every thing because I work 60-80 hours a week and making all the decisions by myself is stressful and he told me there was no way and that it’s not typical for the groom to help so I shouldn’t expect him to and he shouldn’t have to. I just really don’t feel like we are partners in this.

26 Comments

  • M
    Beginner March 2025
    Mads ·
    • Flag
    • Hide content
    View Quoted Comment
    Thanks Gina!


    I definitely get what you’re saying! In our situation we have not too far less than family members (not I
    • Reply
  • M
    Beginner March 2025
    Mads ·
    • Flag
    • Hide content
    View Quoted Comment
    Hi Gina! Thanks for your comment, I started replying and accidentally hit send (at 27 I thought I may understand how to properly use the internet)


    So a little context, we both are from large families, in family over 18 years old the count is almost double what we want/can afford to have a wedding. Cuts will have to be made, people who are married or in long term relationships we are not counting as plus ones they are just invited, in my opinion when you have a s/o you are technically one person, even if it’s two mouths. I don’t feel comfortable with a single family member bringing a plus one over inviting another cousin or uncle.
    At the end of the day these people who wouldn’t have a plus one would be with their parents, siblings and cousins not strangers. We do each have a friend that is single, and they wouldn’t know anyone outside of our parents, my FH and myself. Those two people are really close to us and will literally know no one so we would prioritize giving them a plus one if possible. That is we have to weigh together whether or not the person we have to cut to have our friends plus one there is more important than having our plus one.
    That’s just a little background and how I’m looking at it. If we could afford to have everyone we wanted there maybe it’s all be different but we have a very very tight budget and the people that are coming should be people who share our values, support us consistently, and we both know and care about.
    • Reply
  • M
    Beginner March 2025
    Mads ·
    • Flag
    • Hide content
    View Quoted Comment
    Thank you so much!! I started doing research on cost per head and I think that freaked him out a little bit.


    For his best man he actually doesn’t want that person to be it. He is actually choosing someone that is an overall genuine good person. Today he told me the other guy is a “dick” and he wouldn’t go out of his way to hangout with him or talk to him, this is why I’m confused this person is even on the guest list😂 I asked him why he would want someone he feels that way about to be in our lives and his response was well we grew up together I’m just confused on the rationale, I don’t like him but he’s important enough to be invited😂
    We are definitely taking a break, I literally am dreading thinking about it. We’ve settled on a budget and timeframe so we just need to focus on our savings plan and we’ll can work on it once things have calmed down.
    I appreciate you’re help!!
    • Reply
  • M
    Beginner March 2025
    Mads ·
    • Flag
    • Hide content
    View Quoted Comment
    Hello!


    We have huge families, 100 person guest limit (if we can afford to add a few more based on costs we will but so far it’s not looking promising) just in family over 18 years of age we have almost double our guest limit. People have to get cut.
    We would absolutely invite married couples or longer term relationship partners, to me these people are one. I wouldn’t just invite one of them over for dinner I’d always invite both of them. In the other hand if I invited my single friend or cousin over for dinner at my house I wouldn’t ask them to bring a date. I can’t justify giving a cousin a plus one for someone they just started seeing or their non commuted date over inviting another single cousin. they will be sitting at a table with their siblings, why do you need a new boyfriend with them?
    Could you rebuttals what I said above? Not saying im 100% right I just can’t find the justification behind it so I’m having trouble relating and understanding.
    • Reply
  • M
    Beginner March 2025
    Mads ·
    • Flag
    • Hide content
    View Quoted Comment
    Thanks Andrea!


    I think the etiquette for me is to more help me be logical about who we end up not inviting ya know. I’m not looking at it as this is a wedding rule I’m following it, it’s more so we don’t get to invite a lot of people we care about. Start with our non negotiable must be invited (parents, siblings, close cousin, best friends) then from there I have to justify why someone gets to come over someone else ya know.
    • Reply
  • Jacks
    Rockstar November 2054
    Jacks ·
    • Flag
    • Hide content

    You've got the right idea, you're just confusing the terms.

    Look, if you had a friend (with a boyfriend of 1 year) over for dinner with you and your FI, would you invite the boyfriend too? Yes, probably, right? It's like a couples thing. Inviting her and not inviting him over for dinner would feel weird. That's a good analogy to including someone's partner in the wedding invitation if they are in a relationship. That's not a +1, it's a significant other, like your FI is to you.

    If you and your FI were having a dinner and your truly single, not in a relationship friend wanted to bring like a friend, then no, you're not obligated to invite her friend too. That's the same thing as a plus one in a wedding, and those are totally optional.

    Hope that helps explain it! Good luck with your planning!

    • Reply

You voted for . Add a comment 👇

×
WeddingWire celebrates love ...and so does everyone on our site! Learn more

Groups

WeddingWire article topics