Skip to main content

Post content has been hidden

To unblock this content, please click here

Emily
Beginner November 2019

He doesn't understand the sentiment behind the engagement ring.

Emily, on November 19, 2018 at 3:09 PM

Posted in Family and Relationships 25

My b/f & I have been dating over 3 years after re-uniting after a 12 year part in ways. He has never been married before, and I was married for 11 years to my son's father ( it should be noted that I never had any say in any of the planning for my 1st wedding, since I was only 20 and my mom took...

My b/f & I have been dating over 3 years after re-uniting after a 12 year part in ways. He has never been married before, and I was married for 11 years to my son's father ( it should be noted that I never had any say in any of the planning for my 1st wedding, since I was only 20 and my mom took over). Anyway, We've had the big wedding talks in the last year, and we even went venue hunting to book our venue for next year before our date was booked. He told me earlier this year that he would propose by the end of the year. I assumed Christmas or New Years.

Well, I have plenty of rings I like pinned on Pinterest, and I always keep myself logged in. I told him months ago about the pinterest board for ideas of what I like. I am very simple; I don't like too much bling, I don't like Yellow gold, and I like a slimmer band. Cost is not a big deal to me, as we are both very financially saavy people who don't want to overspend.

He wants the wedding experience. I would be happy celebrating in any way, but I understand that we should celebrate our union because it is our special love story, and I don't want to take the experience away from him. This will be my second and last marriage, and his only, after all.

With all of that said, he mentioned last week that he took a look at my pinterest board and couldn't find my rings I had saved, and he wasn't going to "waste too much time" searching for them. I mentioned that it usually takes 6-8 weeks for a ring to be ordered for pick-up if he was wanting to shop in a store. I'm a little disheartened that he hadn't started the process to research all of the pertinent info that one should know for engagement ring shopping before November. I had told him that I didn't want to pick out my own ring. I'm a romantic at heart, and I really feel strongly that the gesture of a man asking a woman to be his wife should be well-thought out, and he should WANT to make the effort for the grand gesture. I'm happy to point him in the right direction for what I like, which is what I thought I was doing by telling him what I don't like, and saving pictures of rings I do like.

Once I mentioned the 6-8 weeks standard delivery timeline, he said he wanted me to come shop with him to just point out a few rings I like. We did that this past weekend. I'm very simple, as I stated earlier. I don't want him spending too much on a ring, because we do have to pay for our wedding, plus, I don't do what everyone else is doing. i dance to the beat of my own drum, regardless of trends. I don't want him spending the national average of $5-6K on a ring! I also don't want the same ring as 10,000 other women this year, too. You know what I mean? Every ring I showed him was under $2500, respectfully, which is about a half a month's salary for him. Shouldn't be a stretch by any sense of the imagination. He either didn't like some of them, or balked at the price tag if it was over $1200.

I am happy to have a 1/4 carat, or even less, colored gems in lieu of all diamonds, etc. I'm really very easy-going and not hung up on status or materialism. Quality is still important. This ring is a symbol of our love that will be endless. I am very sad now, and I told him I don't want to go shopping for rings together any further. He doesn't think that the ring means that much, but it just does. I value the sentiment of commitment, and show of his happy investment in our future. I will be wearing this ring every day, and I want to have the happy thoughts of him making the romantic gesture with a well-planned proposal every time I look at it. I want him to want to make the effort. Otherwise I feel like he's saying I am not worth the effort of the grand gesture....and THAT spurs some new big questions in my mind just thinking about this.

Am I being ridiculous for wanting the effort and a proper proposal with a modest, quality ring?

25 Comments

  • Emily
    Beginner November 2019
    Emily ·
    • Flag
    • Hide content
    View Quoted Comment
    Gen, that's pretty much how I feel. Maybe I need to be more direct. Thanks.
    • Reply
  • Gen
    Champion June 2019
    Gen ·
    • Flag
    • Hide content
    View Quoted Comment
    No problem, I hope it works out for you! Something that really helps my FH and I, when he is being thickheaded and not seeming to understand what I’m telling him/what I need from him, I write it out in a letter or an email, or even a text. Having it written out forces me to articulate better and having to read it forces him to pay attention more than if he were just listening. Maybe try that!
    • Reply
  • needmorewine
    Expert May 2016
    needmorewine ·
    • Flag
    • Hide content
    View Quoted Comment
    Is he normally romantic and into big romantic gestures? Some people just aren't. If he isn't usually then it's a stretch to expect him to completely change all of a sudden just because you want the proposal to go a certain way. Instead of basing how much he cares about you on the ring buying process, consider how he shows you those things every day. In my opinion, him being ready to secure the venue for the wedding means a great deal about him being ready to get married.
    • Reply
  • PurdyAikey
    Super January 2019
    PurdyAikey ·
    • Flag
    • Hide content

    HI! I haven't read through all of the comments so sorry if this has already been covered, but sometimes putting too much pressure on the ring or having some expectations about how/when he should do it makes it hard for a man to live up. If my FH would have done what I envisioned in my head and picked the ring that I wanted, I would be missing 2 key elements of our proposal story. I always imagined I would say YES, but every time we were somewhere romantic I was ready. He literally proposed before work on a random Thursday, and I freaked out and left to work without realizing the magnitude of whats going on and told him yes over the phone. It is not the most romantic thing ever, but it was SO REAL! He proposed without a ring, and told me he had been waiting so long to propose because he couldn't find the "perfect ring" ... I don't like yellow gold either, so he ended up getting me a silver ring with our birth stones as hearts in the infinity symbol, and said this represents the 2 of us bounded for life. I would have never picked the ring for myself, but now that I have it I WOULD NOT IMAGINE ANYTHING ELSE! He ended up giving me the ring in our special spot (while we were looking for wedding venues), and EVERYTHING ABOUT OUR STORY IS PERFECT BECAUSE IT IS ME AND HIM!!

    He doesn't understand the sentiment behind the engagement ring. 1

    The point of that story is if he is the right man for you, stop putting so much pressure on the ring and the how/when and just focus on the who because if you love him for who he is, the proposal will be perfect whether it is over coffee at home on some random morning with no ring or in the biggest most romantic gesture with a $10k ring!
    Also another thought is that engagement rings are bulky and have brackets that gt caught, and after you get married it may become a special occasion ring. I plan to wear my wedding band all the time, but not my e-ring!

    • Reply
  • KMedcalf
    Dedicated May 2019
    KMedcalf ·
    • Flag
    • Hide content

    So. Just a thought (and hang in there with me)... but that was a very long post to explain something a man could have summed up in like three sentences:

    1.) You want a ring.

    2.) You want a romantic, thoughtful proposal.

    3.) You want him to want to do it. (I SO struggled with this lol)

    After a certain amount of talk, sometimes they just tune out. Is it possible that you have overwhelmed him with it entirely? And, like others, he may already be "on it." I thought my FH was not on it and it turns out he was. He strategically met with two sets of my parents to ask for permission, bought the ring, and didn't fib about whether he had or hadn't when I inquired. I had expectations/ things I wanted/hoped for, and we had a set budget...he exceeded ALL of those things and was super proud of what he picked out. It is possible that your FH just needs time to make decisions and is coming to terms with the price (lets be honest, rings can be expensive lol). I validate all your feelings of wanting it to be a certain way- but you may have to let things be for a hot minute and see what happens Smiley smile

    • Reply

You voted for . Add a comment 👇

×
WeddingWire celebrates love ...and so does everyone on our site! Learn more

Groups

WeddingWire article topics