Honeymoon destination

The Sandals Royal Bahamian will be re-opening early next year so it could also be a great all-inclusive couples only option for you in the Bahamas if that's what you are looking for. All-inclusive options in the Bahamas is very limited. Sandals Ochi is a great option. For all of the things you mentioned. I would recommend going with a butler level offering at Sandals Ochi. That will ensure all of the service options and a great suite. As far as food at all-inclusive resorts are concerned Karisma resorts and Sandals resorts pretty much have the best food experiences. The Karisma resorts are primarily in Mexico and Dominican republic. There is one Karisma resort in Jamaica under the AZUL branding, but I think you'd get a better experience for a honeymoon at Sandals since AZUL is a family brand. This youtube video gives some more information about the Sandals butler service and specifically calls out Sandals Ochi as the most accessible Sandals resort for butler level suits. Sandals Butler Video

Hi Cheryl! Have you thought about St. Lucia as a honeymoon destination?? There's lots of hiking and ATV excursions, as well as beaches and adults-only all-inclusive resorts!

St. Lucia Honeymoon Guide

If Jamaica and the Bahamas are your top two choices I think I'd go with Jamaica!! There are more eco-minded activities and on-land excursion options in Jamaica, whereas the Bahamas are more about beaches and water activities! You can check out recommendations for each destination in the links below:

Bahamas Honeymoon Guide

Jamaica Honeymoon Guide

Do not worry all-inclusive plans since these plans are crafted for profits of the hotels and resorts. Choose the place that you like the best and book your tours in segments. Ensure to try out local delicacies as well for a best experience.