Skip to main content

Post content has been hidden

To unblock this content, please click here

Shelly
Just Said Yes October 2023

i do- take two - vow renewal/jewish wedding

Shelly, on May 30, 2022 at 1:45 PM Posted in Planning 0 4
So - my wife and I (we're lesbian) have been married for 9 years, but we had a civil elopement with no family or friends present (we married civilly in another state pre-Obergefell decision, and could not afford a wedding at the time - our whole shindig was $200, including the cost of the marriage certificate).


We didn't have nice dresses - just cheap clearance workwear to get married in. We always intended to get around to a bigger shindig later. Our families still give us no end of crap for not actually having a 'wedding'.
Fast forward to now - we've changed religions (converted to Judaism) and my wife's father has dementia. We are now finally planning the wedding we didn't get to have due to circumstances and finances a decade ago and want to do it before her dad isn't lucid enough to participate. (And before someone nitpicks as I have seen in other threads, this shindig will involve signing a religious marriage contract (Ketubah) and the other mandatory religious ceremonial components of a Jewish wedding (modified because we are same-sex - a reform cantor will be officiating), so yes, it *is* actually a wedding, not just a vow renewal).
We did not have any of the pre-wedding components of a wedding the first time around either - no bachelorette party, no bridal shower, etc before our civil wedding. I plan to do a welcome brunch for out of town family or some sort of sip and paint do before the ceremony next year but that is about it. (I generally dislike being the centre of attention, and it seems odd to do those other pre-wedding things when I've been civilly married for almost a decade).
I also keep seeing that I shouldn't purchase a wedding gown on ettiquette sites but seeing as that I got married in a $20 clearance workwear dress from Ross Dress for Less that doubled as an interview outfit after the fact - I kinda feel like I'm entitled (and so is my wife) to wear whatever the hell we want (also, I'm her second marriage and she's never gotten to wear a wedding gown for either of her weddings). Kinda want to see other's thoughts on that topic. Since we're having the religious do (at a synagogue, no less) would it be weird to wear actual wedding dresses?
We are not asking for gifts (don't need them but if someone wants to give us cards, well wishes, or money I won't say no). This is planned to be a decent sized do, with about 120 people. We're planning to do most of the normal wedding stuff at the reception (though there will be no garter toss and no bouquet toss because I really find that stuff kinda tacky. We will have a first dance and a father-daughter dance for my wife (my bio dad is not invited and I feel awkward about dancing with my mum for that), and a thing with families with kids since we have a now adult daughter. Also we are planning the normal Jewish reception stuff, like the hora. (We're also skipping some things like the bedeken. I won't be wearing a long ass veil anyway due to having *very* short hair - I found a wire headpiece on Poshmark that looks kinda kippah-esque and will have that on instead).
But yeah - is anyone else here doing 'I Do - Take Two' for religious/cultural, or vow renewal reasons? Curious about other's thoughts on this. I can't be the only one planning on doing the religious wedding after the civil one. (FWIW - This seems to be a thing that is less common in the US where I live now - I grew up in Europe (I'm from Germany) where this is normalized because many countries have a requirement for couples to civilly marry and then have a religious ceremony separately if they choose to). We've gotten some weird comments when discussing planning with friends though so I'm just kinda at a loss I guess. Seems like Americans may have some odd cultural hangups about this sort of thing? Let me know what you think.





4 Comments

Latest activity by Paige, on June 1, 2022 at 5:47 PM
  • W
    VIP September 2020
    Willow ·
    • Flag
    • Hide content
    You should absolutely wear a wedding dress, do the whole wedding party celebration, etc. What you wear is not a question of etiquette. Have the bridal moment you never got.


    People have weird hang ups when couples pretend they're not legally married already, want to do a redo wedding super soon after they already had a full blown affair, or do 2 redundant affairs close in time because one happened to be a destination wedding (making the guest invites seemed tiered), etc.
    This is a 9 year vow renewal when you never had a "big" wedding in the first place, no gifts expected, and you're adding a religious element. Such a celebration near the 10 year mark isn't going to be frowned on by most people.
    The only "off" thing I see about your idea is the sip and paint. If you want to hang out with friends, have a sip and paint not connected to your marital celebrations. Religous ceremony or no, you've been married 9 years. Pre wedding celebrations come with added pressure to attend and are an extra request to celebrate you, 9 years after the fact. Also, etiquette dictates that the guest of honor (you) should not host or plan such a party in your own honor, even if you weren't married yet. Someone else offers or you don't have it at all.
    • Reply
  • Shelly
    Just Said Yes October 2023
    Shelly ·
    • Flag
    • Hide content
    View Quoted Comment
    Eh - the paint and sip thing is less of a 'come celebrate us' thing and more of a 'hey, just come hang out and do something fun if you're free and want to' idea. My sister wants to throw *something* for us (I was her MOH a few years ago, and she feels guilty because I got *none* of the pre wedding experience). Personally I'm ok with just hosting a 'welcome to town' brunch for our out of town relatives at my home or something at my own expense before the ceremony but my sister is insisting on doing something and 'paint and sip' was the only thing I could come up with to do that wasn't super too obviously bridal-shower-y or bachlorette-party-esque since I have done them for work teambuilders and birthday parties too).
    • Reply
  • C
    Master January 2019
    Cassidy ·
    • Flag
    • Hide content
    Go for it, go all out of that’s what you want!
    It’s not weird or super uncommon. My parents got married civilly and then had a religious wedding 10 years later. They kept it simple, my mom wore a nice pant suit. But we had a celebration with a fancy cake after. But I didn’t think there’s anything wrong with having a big celebration.
    • Reply
  • Paige
    VIP October 2022
    Paige ·
    • Flag
    • Hide content

    Before covid something like this may not have been a super common thing, but I think now that so many people had to have a super truncated version of the wedding they wanted, having a larger celebration later on has become more commonplace. I say do whatever it is that brings you joy. Wear a wedding gown, have a paint-and-sip, and enjoy your day the way you see fit. Life's way too short (and we've all been way too deprived of joy courtesy of covid) to shape your life with someone else's mold.

    • Reply

You voted for . Add a comment 👇

×

Related articles

WeddingWire celebrates love ...and so does everyone on our site! Learn more

Groups

WeddingWire article topics