Skip to main content

Post content has been hidden

To unblock this content, please click here

Kimberly
Beginner December 2019

Newly engaged: holiday between families, future mother in law wearing my ring, and they want to see each other every couple weeks

Kimberly, on December 1, 2019 at 4:12 PM

Posted in Family and Relationships 31

I've got a few issues, and the solutions my friends proposed are not viable. Any advice on whether to say anything, and if so, what? I've been engaged for a few months. Honestly, I feel like I'm ready to "speak my mind" which probably won't end well. Here are my problems: 1) Holiday Divide: Both...

I've got a few issues, and the solutions my friends proposed are not viable. Any advice on whether to say anything, and if so, what? I've been engaged for a few months. Honestly, I feel like I'm ready to "speak my mind" which probably won't end well. Here are my problems:

1) Holiday Divide: Both our families celebrate major holidays. Originally, our plan was to spend Thanksgiving at one family and Christmas at the other, then switch next year. I thought that's perfectly reasonable and normal. My parents have always done that (Having them come to us is not an option in our small, new home). When my fiance told them, his mother and sisters caused a ton of nonstop, weeks-long drama. My fiance "put his foot down" w/them but it's not helping. Because of this, I couldn't spend thanksgiving dinner with my grandma who just found out she had cancer. Both our families planned on Thanksgiving dinner in the evening so it was a pick-one situation. It also looks like I won't be able to spend time with my family on Christmas. Despite the fact this year we are doing everything with them, they are still bitter because they normally demand everyone go out of town to a city a few hours away for a few days for another Christmas celebration with their family friends. My fiance has had several conversations with them, but they "don't understand" why my family events can't be moved to other dates to fit their schedule. Advice? Should I talk to them directly? Lately, I've just been ignoring them/the problem but it's annoying considering normally I'd face this directly.

2) Future mother in law wears my ring: once, my future mother in law asked to see my ring to see how it fits. I showed her, and she asked to see it off my finger. She then puts it on her ring finger, and comments on how it doesn't fit her. Then, on Thanksgiving, my future sister in law wanted to see the ring. Again, the future mother in law puts it on her ring finger and comments happily about how it's a perfect fit for her now that it's been resized. It's just weird. Is this normal behavior? I can absolutely see this becoming a regular thing. From now on, I won't take it off. But I want to know if there's some sort of underlying reason she does this? Because all the women in my family would never do that because it's just for me/my fiance.

3) They want to see us every couple weeks: his family is very tightly knit. I see my family every couple weeks, but I go to see them directly w/out my fiance and usually only for an hour. His family will come with short notice (once I got about 2 hours notice while we were moving into a new house). They invite him to events every couple weeks, ask to come over (and when they come over it lasts half a day), and even if we go out to eat they then invite themselves over to the house for hours. If we say "we are busy" they will simply reschedule and if we say "no" they take it personally. Advice on how to handle this?

31 Comments

  • P
    January 2014
    Pam ·
    • Flag
    • Hide content

    You were forced into Thanksgiving with them and for a particularly difficult one at that. FH needs to TELL them that the two of you will be spending this Christmas with your family. You guys can visit them on the day before or after.

    • Reply
  • W
    VIP September 2020
    Willow ·
    • Flag
    • Hide content
    Your FH didn't put his foot down. He gave in. You didn't get to see your ill grandma on Thanksgiving, and now it seems like he's caving on Christmas. I would go see grandma on my own for Christmas, even if that meant spending a holiday separate from my FH. I mean it. I'd tell FH, you're free to join me or not, but I'll be with grandma since I couldn't spend Thanksgiving with her.


    Why does your MIL care if your ring fits her? If she were some single friend who wanted to see how a rock looked on her finger, or if she just wanted to try it on once, that would not be so odd. Is she hoping to inherit it after she breaks up your relationship? She reminds me of that MIL who tried on the bride's wedding dress and took a batch of dried flowers into the room with her (presumably to see how she looked in her SON'S BRIDE's dress with a bouquet.)
    If your husband wants to see his family every other week, you don't have to go with him. You're allowed to have "separate" time.
    If your FH doesn't set boundaries now, he never will. His family sounds inherently selfish and oddly emeshed.
    • Reply
  • Jameelah
    Dedicated July 2021
    Jameelah ·
    • Flag
    • Hide content
    Do what makes the two of you happy and if they get mad it’s their problem.
    • Reply
  • Rebecca
    Master August 2019
    Rebecca ·
    • Flag
    • Hide content

    What everyone has already said: your FH didn't put his foot down, he tried to, and then his entire family ganged up on him. This sounds like a learned pattern, so this is likely to be difficult for him. You both need to say to his family, "Bride's family is just as important. We will be spending time with them. Any and all comments about this will reflect on the speaker, not the bride and groom. In addition, her grandmother is ill, bride would appreciate support at this time."

    And then do it. Go to your family for Christmas. FH can mute his phone, so if they blow it up complaining, he can't hear it. Set a time to video chat with them, and be ruthless about the time and the legnth of the call. If they don't answer, that is on them. If they refuse to hang up, "love you, bye, END CALL." They were warned.

    If you do not nip this in the bud, now, it will only get worse. I'm sorry.


    I would never take my ring off for someone else to look at. Tell anyone who wants it off your finger, "no." No excuses, no reasons, just, "NO." (Rude people will not like that. It reflects on them, not you.)


    As for giving you no notice for visiting? Well, there's the eminently practical - locked doors, and don't answer the doorbell/phone. There's the TMI: "...You want grandkids? GIVE US ALONE TIME." There's the fun/but also petty: When they give you no notice, invent reasons to be out of the house - grocery shopping, date night, visiting YOUR family, work event, neighborhood event, etc. Just go out and bonus if you pass them as they try to come over. There's also the super petty: put 'em to work. They come over as you're moving? Great, you needed a break, and that box has to go all the way upstairs. Oh, you don't want to do that? Awesome, are you going out to get dinner? Kitchen isn't unpacked yet. Oh, you don't want to do that? We'll see you later, as you can see... we're busy!


    You are both adults, and you need to organize a way to deal with this together. Stressors like this can make or break a relationship.

    • Reply
  • Alejandra
    Super March 2019
    Alejandra ·
    • Flag
    • Hide content

    Wow, sounds like my MIL sometimes, she's been married with my hubby's stepdad now for like 20 something years and she never had a ring because she couldn't wear it to work and didn't like wearing fancy things, fast forward to literally the week of my wedding and both MIL & SFIL tell me that they have ordered wedding ring sets for them and she tried to ind one that looked like mine but she could not. Thankfully our rings look nothing a like but that totally freaked me out. She always insisted that we had to go to her house early and stay there until late many times offering my hubby drinks so that he'd stay longer and try and convince us to just stay there until the next day. If my family had a xmas celebration on the same day she'd try and ask us for things that would force us to be there much longer than we wanted to and made me cut down my own family time. Eventually my husband felt like we were getting pulled way too much from his family and I mentioned it to him that we always go there and they can go with us to my family events if they want but they never want to leave their house so its complicated. But my husband told his mom that we were not going to leave my family's stuff early each time just because she had something going on. As a matter of fact some holidays we have not been able to get together with either families so its jut the way the ball bounces now. Once we have kids we will like to host big holidays and avoid travel for ourselves so we'll see how that goes. It's really something your FH should stand up for but honestly if the subject is brought up in your presence I'd just state that you both want to celebrate with both families and will try and make it to both evenly.

    • Reply
  • Kimberly
    Beginner December 2019
    Kimberly ·
    • Flag
    • Hide content
    View Quoted Comment
    Yikes, sounds like your MIL took it a step further and I hope mine does not do that. It’s so weird! Honestly I wish they would bring it up in my presence so we can just settle it and move on but I guess it’s just something my FH just needs to handle on his own.
    • Reply
  • Alejandra
    Super March 2019
    Alejandra ·
    • Flag
    • Hide content
    View Quoted Comment

    Yeah its too much, when she got the ring I told my husband " I am sorry but if your Mom gets a ring like mine, I am going to be pretty uncomfortable and upset". The funny thing is that she never wears it anyway. She would compare herself to me and wanted to get her hair cut like mine and wear clothes like I did. I mean it was a compliment but I married her son and thats my life, not hers. We together as a couple get to decide when and how we spend our time and if going through your FH doesn't go well, I'd just bring it up super nonchalant about how excited you both are to do stuff with both families and that you guys really want to be spending equal amounts of time with both. Don't let her run the conversation just tell r what you have decided to do as a couple and if she throws a fit then your FH needs to tell her that its unnecessary and he doesn't want her this to cause drama because it is stressful for both of you.

    • Reply
  • Samantha
    Savvy October 2020
    Samantha ·
    • Flag
    • Hide content
    Your FH and you need to establish boundaries with his family now. If you don’t, his family will play a bigger role in your marriage than it sounds like you want them to. This will ultimately lead to resentment towards your husband and you don’t want that. For the holidays, tell them firmly that you will be spending one with them and one with your family, that it’s been decided and that it’s not up for negotiation. Your fiancé has to back you up on this since it’s his family. As to the ring, that is weird but not taking it off is the best solution you have. For the surprise visits, establish boundaries and remain firm. Tell them they can’t stop by randomly. Again, stuck to your guns and have your fiancé back you.
    • Reply
  • Alejandra
    Super November 2021
    Alejandra ·
    • Flag
    • Hide content
    View Quoted Comment
    This. All of this.
    • Reply
  • A
    Savvy August 2020
    Amanda ·
    • Flag
    • Hide content

    You've got some JustNo's on your hands. "Putting your foot down" doesn't work if you backtrack and give them what they want.


    My advice? Stop worry about upsetting them and stop acting sorry when you do. They are always going to want more. You two are starting a new family together, it's time to assert yourselves as individuals that deserve respect.

    • Reply
  • Haley
    Expert October 2020
    Haley ·
    • Flag
    • Hide content

    1. This is exactly why I like doing holidays completely separate. I'm not sure if this is an option for you (I didn't read through all the comments before answering). We have our thing with our friends Christmas Eve, but other than that, he goes his way and I go mine. It works best for us.

    2. I guess the solution here is to stop taking your ring off? Sounds like his mother is used to being the main woman in his life and wants that attention on herself.

    3. I'm thinking this should settle down once you guys are married and/or really settled into a routine. Has he lived away from home before you guys moved in together? Sometimes parents/mothers/families want to establish that he (or you if it was your family doing it) is still in THEIR family and they don't want to be replaced by you (or your family). Which is dumb but I think that's why they do it.

    • Reply

You voted for . Add a comment 👇

×
WeddingWire celebrates love ...and so does everyone on our site! Learn more

Groups

WeddingWire article topics