Not sure Two Matrons of Honor

Hello melissa.
You can have 2 Maids/Matrons of honor.
It's pretty common, probably not the 'majority' but common.My brother had 2 best men and my sister in-law ( his wife) had 1 maid of honor + 1 matron.In your situation, having both girls as matrons would make everyone happy, including you!

You can do whatever you want! I have 2 maid of honors (my bestfriend and my sister)

You can have 2! i had two and then i was a part of a bridal party where i was the 2nd MOH

You do you boo, I am having 2 matron of honors i couldn't decide between my best friend and sister

I originally had two but one turned into a moh-zilla and is no longer in the picture. Husband is having two best men though still.