This is such a dumb dilemma, but I'm still having hard time deciding.
Our venue offers heavy duty paper plates and styrofoam cups for free. They also offer china to rent, which is roughly $3 extra per person (dinner plate, glass, silverware only), plus a $100 fee for dish washing. We are having between 120-150 people (no set number right now due to my indecisiveness), so that's $460-$550 extra for china.
If the wedding was outside, I'd go with the paper. But, the wedding is inside a fire hall (I'm so Western PA, it hurts...).
And we're trying for a cheap wedding. But I don't want a wedding I regret.
Rational ersatzpnk is saying go with paper. Vain ersatzpnk says go with china. What would you do?