Smear proof lipstick?

This stuff is AWESOME!

First of all, how smear-proof do you need it? If you were eating pizza, the oils in the pizza broke-down the lipstick, which caused it to come off. Oil is the best way to remove makeup, intentionally or not. If you're worried about it being kiss-proof, you might be ok. But if you're worried about it coming off when you eat, then you might want to find another lipstick or be prepared to re-apply it throughout the night.

If you want to try to use that Vice lipstick, before you return it, try to set it using setting powder. Put the lipstick on, and blot with a tissue like you normally would to remove the excess product. Then take a clean piece of tissue and hold it tightly over your lips with your lips apart (make an "O" with your mouth). Take some setting powder and brush it over the tissue paper over your lips. This will allow just a little bit of powder to get through and will help set your lipstick. I actually find toilet paper to be the best way to do this if you tear apart the toilet paper so it's only 1-ply -- the thinner the better.

Unfortunately, because of how matte lipstick dries, it really brings out the lines in lips for anyone. If you're worried about the lines, I would stay away from liquid matte lipsticks because the liquid formula sinks into the lip lines -- try a solid matte lipstick if that's the look you want. Satin lipsticks or high-pigmented glosses are a bit more forgiving. If you really want a matte look and have a satin lip color you love, you could try setting the satin lip color with powder directly (no tissue) or use a product like Smashbox's Insta-Matte Lipstick Transformer. Layer it on top of your satin lipstick and it will make it matte.