Skip to main content

Post content has been hidden

To unblock this content, please click here

S
Savvy September 2023

The Age Old Struggle of Picking Bridal Party

Sophia, on October 7, 2022 at 8:42 AM Posted in Family and Relationships 0 9

So my best friend from college is my MOH (just asked her last week) & I’m SO excited for that. She’s awesome.

I’ve been planning to ask my 2 sisters (I’m the youngest of 3) to be BMs as well as my FSIL (I love her & already know she is going to be one of the most helpful people for me while planning.)
FH & I agreed on 4 each in our parties. My conflict is that I have 2 other close friends (A - been close since 14 & went to college together. And T - close friend from college who has helped me with a lot of personal stuff. A & I are both also her MOHs for her upcoming wedding.)
I asked FH if he’d care if I had 6 & he had 4 & he didn’t like the idea. I think it’d make him feel lame, especially bc he is struggling to pick his final 4. I think he feels solid on at least 2 but a couple of his friends can sometimes be flaky so it’s stressing him out. I don’t care if they are imbalanced but I also understand that he’d be the one w less & that doesn’t feel good, so I respect his stance on this. FBIL (FSIL’s husband) will be a GM.
Part of me knows that I should probably just stick w the sisters & my best friend, but then I think…well what if I didn’t ask any of the sisters & had 4 close friends? I know I’m not unique in this struggle but I’m torn between what I know I’ll probably end up doing (sisters & best friend) and what sounds more fun (all friends). Honestly wish there was a way to have my FSIL & 3 friends but no way can I pick FSIL & not my actual sisters.
I am already planning to have A & T at my bachelorette as well as some other friends. FH suggested I just ask A & T to join while I’m getting ready, but I worry they’d feel out of place since they wouldn’t actually be in the bridal party…
If it offers any needed context: FH & I are planning to have a smallish church ceremony w about 60 guests, followed by a dinner-only reception at a nice restaurant.

9 Comments

Latest activity by Courtney, on October 10, 2022 at 9:37 AM
  • N/A
    Beginner August 2022
    N/A ·
    • Flag
    • Hide content
    Just an idea- You could have A & T be your “something blue” one of my good friends did this at her wedding. The girls wore blue dresses (of their choice) and sat up front. This could honor them in a way without making it uneven but also making A & T feel special.


    This same friend also had 6 bridesmaids and there were 4 groomsmen, and from a guest perspective the “uneven-ness” didn’t look bad or anything. Hope everything works out!
    • Reply
  • Jacks
    Rockstar November 2054
    Jacks ·
    • Flag
    • Hide content

    I hope it works out. It's hard when you have to treat your friendships like numbers on a side of a wedding party. I suppose you could have your friends be involved without being in the wedding party, but it might feel to them like they're "second best".

    Really, the trend is toward uneven wedding parties, it's not like friends and family come in matched sets.

    You have awhile before you need to ask anyone. I would suggest January of 2023 to ask them.

    • Reply
  • S
    Savvy September 2023
    Sophia ·
    • Flag
    • Hide content
    View Quoted Comment
    I don’t want anyone to feel like they are second best or anything like that. Part of me just says to leave it at having my best friend, sisters, and SIL and that’s that. They’ll see that I went the family route and might be disappointed but I’m sure they’d understand. They are super sweet and would never try to make me feel bad for it. I feel like I should just decide to not even worry about it.


    But I’m a worrier so here I am haha. You do have a fair point that I can wait awhile, still. I don’t actually have a wedding date set yet haha I really need to figure that out. I’m guessing it will be late summer/early fall of 2023
    • Reply
  • R
    Rockstar
    Rosebud ·
    • Flag
    • Hide content

    This such a tough one if it s really important to you to have them at your side I d let your fh know that and if he wants to add 1 or 2 more he s welcome too. If the sides are uneven so be it what matters most is that you have the people you want and need at your side at such an important moment. Another option would be if you are having a ceremony with readings you can ask your friends to each do a reading or in a catholic mass you usually need people to bring up the communion gifts. Best of luck to youSmiley heart

    • Reply
  • Ashlee
    Super September 2022
    Ashlee ·
    • Flag
    • Hide content

    My husband knew he needed at least 6, potentially 7 groomsmen. The issue I ran into was that I don't really have a ton of CLOSE friends anymore. I was in several college friends weddings, but I was a single mom at 20 while they were still partying and then when they started having families, my child was already 10 so we just naturally grew apart. I love them all, still invited them, but we're not close. So I really struggled with coming up with people to "match" numbers. I asked my best friend, another close friend, my sister, my cousin who grew up like another sister, and my two SILs. So I had 6 to match. my one close friend ended up not being able to financially afford it. So I had 5 at that point. I chose to not replace her but the uneven numbers really didn't look that out of place. We had one bridesmaid walk with two groomsmen and you barely notice it in pics.

    The Age Old Struggle of Picking Bridal Party 1

    So if having all 6 is what would make you happiest, and they're the people nearest and dearest and you don't want to exclude any, I would just have another conversation with your FH about it, maybe he can add at least 1 more if he's worried about how it will look and doesn't have 2.

    • Reply
  • Jacks
    Rockstar November 2054
    Jacks ·
    • Flag
    • Hide content
    View Quoted Comment

    Lovely photo Ashlee! I totally agree.

    • Reply
  • Mrs.evans
    VIP October 2022
    Mrs.evans ·
    • Flag
    • Hide content
    Hi Annika and Congratulations to you both and I know how hard that is when it comes to that decisions. I was also going to ask some closes friends my 2 besties but as talking in length about to get feedback from them before making the decision on who it was. And then my FSIL but she will be helping my FMIL and she also didn't want to be put on the spot. So we asked our kids to stand for us it will be its 4 each on both sides. We wanted to share this journey with them all of them are grown and I have my sister from another mother. She is is 1 of my MOHS I have 2 my calm and also my voice when there is a problem and stops me from reacting. She couldn't make it for my dress shopping I had 2 that was there I was able to enjoy that moment with easy and its was a emotional moment to we all cried even the all of the consultants too. Now we have bumped head a few times with the kids and man through the wedding planning process now that we are so close to the finish line. So you just choose who will be calming once things get alittle hecked that you can turn too. And then the fun one and 1 the that can pull it in when things get out of control. Its seems like the women that you have chosen fits all of those things but remember a tip💡Stay firm on your decisions they can sway your there way you will or will not make everyone happy. You have the last decision maker but I really hope that you enjoy your wedding planning
    • Reply
  • S
    Super September 2022
    Sarah ·
    • Flag
    • Hide content

    One suggestion to even it out could be having your FSIL stand on your fiance's side! She could still help you plan and go to your bachelorette party and everything, but that would just even out the sides a little so you could have your 2 sisters and 3 friends, and then he has his 4 guys and 1 sister.

    • Reply
  • C
    Savvy October 2023
    Courtney ·
    • Flag
    • Hide content

    Are you having children at your wedding? My friend just did a child-free wedding and had one of her friends be the "flower maiden" and it worked really well! You could have A & T be Flower Maiden and Ring Barer.

    I get having uneven sides too. I have 8.5 Bridesmaids (my cousin's daughter is a Jr so she's my half lol) and my FH is at 5 Groomsmen (and that was a struggle to get). Our family and friend situation is just different! My friend group is mostly female and we have all branched out. His is co-ed and they all married each other. I have family close by and he doesn't. At the end of the day, the number of people in your party doesn't matter. Just that you're happy.

    • Reply

You voted for . Add a comment 👇

×

Related articles

WeddingWire celebrates love ...and so does everyone on our site! Learn more

Groups

WeddingWire article topics