Skip to main content

Post content has been hidden

To unblock this content, please click here

E
Rockstar August 2023

Three Way Wedding Faceoff: DJ vs. Live Musician(s) vs. Live Band

Elly, on May 21, 2024 at 2:09 AM Posted in Community Conversations 0 1

Music is essential to weddings in establishing the mood. This post is here as a guide with considerations. Ultimately the choice is yours, and you are encouraged to weigh in!

Category 1: DJ

Today’s DJ is usually a single person with a computerized equipment and accessory hardware (ie: speakers, turn-tables, headset, microphones, lights, cold sparklers, etc.) that oversees music and sound throughout the event. This typically includes the speaking part of the ceremony where couples are saying their vows, and can include helping a live musician, such as a harpist, with their sound. Some DJs may have an assistant to help them in transporting the equipment, and as a backup. DJs also double as the Master of Ceremonies (MC) with your wedding planner and/or venue coordinator to lead guests from one event of the wedding to the other.

DJ Pros:
-DJs have a variety of music genres to accommodate multiple musical tastes.

-DJs can have plenty of insider knowledge when it comes to venues and vendors in an area as they may have had to work in different locations.

-DJs are often a fraction of the cost of live wedding bands, with the average being around $2,500-$3,500.
-It can be easier to find a DJ across the states than musicians and a live band.
-Unless a DJ is tied to a venue, most DJs expect to travel within a certain radius.

-There are plenty of resources and events DJs can use and attend to refine their craft.

DJ Cons:
-Weather, particularly extreme heat and water can affect and potentially destroy DJ equipment.

-Not every DJ will have “back up” equipment as it can be costly.

-Some DJs may not be as versed in certain genres of music if weddings of a certain culture are not as prominent in an area, or if they are unfamiliar with the lyrics. This may mean you need to establish a relationship with your DJ based on comfort and trust- you would feel blind sighted if you were playing explicit/offensive music in a language you are not fluent in and didn’t realize it.
(Examples: Indian or Middle Eastern Music, Klezmer music, Afro beats, Dance Hall, K-pop, and regional music/ corridos)

Important Note: Not every DJ is a good wedding DJ. DJs that are more versed at working in a club may have no idea how to set the right ambiance for a wedding, or transition from one event in the wedding to another.



Category 2: A live musician/ live musicians

Musicians are masters of their instrument or instruments. They usually specialize in reading music theory (musical notes), and in a few genres. Most musicians will be trained in classical music, and then in some contemporary music as well for several years. Typically, a live musician will play for the ceremony and cocktail hour, unless asked to play for additional time.

Musician Pros:

-Seeing and hearing a live musician has a different (and literal) resonation with the audience.

-Musicians can add the “extra” element of wonder in setting up a wedding vibe whether the music is classical, or contemporary.

-Musicians can play covers of contemporary songs, and this can mean that you won’t have to worry about explicit lyrics being sung in front of guests.


-Musicians can have multiple instruments and may know which is best to bring to your event in terms of acoustics.


-Musicians can usually work with DJs and take turns or breaks.


Musician Cons:
-Weather may affect instruments, especially if a wedding is outdoors.

-Unless you give your musician(s) a break, fatigue may affect how an instrument is played.


-Musicians, like live bands are usually subject to the harsh realities of “gigs”. It may mean that you can’t book them over a year in advance, and/or if you don’t book quickly, the musician may book another event.


-Certain musicians that specialize in certain instruments or play at a certain caliber may reside far away. It is expected that the client (aka: bride and groom) pay for the travel and the lodging.

-Musician pricing may be more subject to inflation, especially if they are just starting out, or working alone.


-It is expected that musicians typically play for no more than 2 hours at a wedding. More time can always be requested, but pricing can go up quickly.

Important Note:

Live musicians can be a lovely element to weddings that place importance on religious ceremonies and rituals.


Category 3: Live Bands

When it comes to making a musical statement, a live band makes an impact. Live bands consist of three or more musicians that sing and/or play instruments. Typically, a live band comes in during the wedding reception rather than a ceremony and cocktail hour.

Live Band Pros:

-It is almost impossible to deny the stage presence and energy of a band.

-Members of a band can range from being self-taught to playing/touring with top music industry talent.
-If you have a particular niche taste in music that you gravitate to rather than a variety, a band can amplify and showcase the genre tastefully. Examples: Big band (swing), R&B, Blues, Caribbean, and Country.

Live Band Cons:

-Wedding bands are usually more expensive than a DJ, and even a DJ and a single musician combined. The typical starting cost will be around $3,500 or more.

-Not every venue is accommodating of a band in terms of space, or power (electrical) use.

-Bands may clash with potential noise ordinances.

-Typically, bands and DJs are not at the same event due to the attention and focus that a band draws.

-Bands will usually be in urban areas, and clients will be expected to pay for travel and accommodations if a wedding is not within a certain radius.

-Some bands may not be able to play a wide range of music or music genres.



The Verdict: The DJ

Hiring a DJ is the best, cost-effective investment for weddings due to their versatility in music, event skill set, and potential to work with a single live musician, or a small group of live musicians.

Was this helpful? Did I miss anything? Do you have a different opinion?

What weddings have you been to that had these options and made them a success or failure?

What will you be choosing for your own wedding?

Comment below!

1 Comments

Latest activity by Michelle, on May 22, 2024 at 11:44 AM
  • Michelle
    Rockstar December 2022
    Michelle ·
    • Flag
    • Hide content
    We decided on a dj. We wanted to hear songs by original artists or mixes. A number of weddings we attended in the past have had great success with the djs. We didn’t want or need an MC. While we haven’t seen them in real life, we were not sold on the vibe they have and constant talking that so many do in their promo videos. The djs we have seen that had people on the dance floor the whole time barely spoke and guests were not confused by a lack of talking by the dj (announcing events as they happen) unless something is completely out of the ordinary. Even friends with experience with the hype MCs said they zone out and follow the organic flow, and that rarely is there anything confusing going on. We specifically didn’t want a wedding dj vibe, and we were not opposed to playing some explicit songs even with kids or elders in attendance. The elders in the guest list were nowhere near as easily offended as some tend to be that you read about, and the kids are used to parents playing specific artists and genres. We had in mind to have more of a club vibe and that’s what we had. Even at weddings we have attended with a dj, as long as 5 people out of 200 are constantly on the dance floor together, that is a win. The dj also played music for the ceremony.


    The only time we have heard/seen live musicians is when they are required by a house of worship.
    Never seen a live band at a wedding. It wasn’t a consideration because they are limited to one genre and may not sing music how people are used to and are out of budget.
    • Reply

You voted for . Add a comment 👇

×
WeddingWire celebrates love ...and so does everyone on our site! Learn more

Groups

WeddingWire article topics