Where did the proposal happen?

On my birthday at a beach bar. Salt Shack! Babylon, NY

We got engaged in Cinderella's Castle at Disney World! We are big Disney nerds, and it was our 3rd trip to WDW together. We were already secretly planning the wedding and had a few things booked (we wanted to make sure we could get married in 2019), but I was as surprised as if I'd had no idea.

OMG! It caught me totally by surprise!!! We were at church!! He invited all of our friends and family and I was totally baffled!!! It was truly the most beautiful thing he has said to me and it was great knowing he felt that way!!

He proposed while we were in Barcelona, Spain. We went to Magic Fountain of Montjuic and it was wonderfully unexpected! He was planning on proposing in March when we were supposed to go to Spain but our plans were postponed and he decided to wait until our actual trip in July.

He surprised me while I was on a trip in Israel and proposed in Jerusalem on the Mt. of Olives overlooking the city and Temple Mount.

He proposed in Breckenridge, Colorado at the top of the Imperial Express Superchair in the middle of a blizzard at 12,840ft (tallest ski lift in North America).

I was browsing pinterest and I saw a quote that struck me in the right way. I then sent it to him and asked him to marry me. I told him to take his time to think it over, and two days later he said yes.

If he will humour me, I'd like to do a proper face to face proposal with him when we meet again.

He proposed outside of his church on the Thursday before Valentine’s Day, because I had told him I would say no to a Valentine’s Day proposal. Dressed as a knight.

I messaged him asking him to marry me late at night, so I could wake up to his answer... But it didn't work out that way, as he took 2 days to answer. I told him he could think about it, as I knew I'd have caught him totally off guard.